Best Pizza in
Washington

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Washington to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
80.4
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Seattle
highest avg. score in Washington
Verified Deliveries
20
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
1
Seattle

State Hall of Fame

Pizzeria Pulcinella
State Elite
1
Pizzeria Pulcinella
87.00
Score
10003 Rainier Ave S, Seattle, WA 98178, USA

Pizzeria Pulcinella offers a range of pies, some achieving notable flavor profiles. The red sauce, notably fresh and clean, complements a calzone large enough to yield significant leftovers. While some pizzas exhibit a crisp, well-cooked dough, others suffer from an overwhelming greasiness and a sweetness that detracts from the overall balance.

The establishment's atmosphere, punctuated by Italian music and wall art, aims for an authentic feel, though this is not consistently met by the food. Certain dishes, like the burrata with its flavorful pesto, stand out. However, other pizzas have been described as heavy, difficult to digest, and inducing thirst, a departure from expected Neapolitan standards.

Service at Pizzeria Pulcinella is noted for its efficiency and easegoing nature, with staff accommodating substitutions without issue. Servers like McKenzi are highlighted for their attentiveness. Despite varied experiences with the pizzas themselves, the friendly demeanor of the staff provides a consistent positive note.

Palermo Pizza & Pasta Capitol Hill
State Elite
2
Palermo Pizza & Pasta Capitol Hill
86.21
Score
350 15th Ave E, Seattle, WA 98112, USA

The scent of garlic and baking dough greets patrons upon entry into Palermo Pizza & Pasta, a compact space where the aroma suggests traditional preparation. The chicken Marsala pasta arrives generously sauced, its flavors pronounced. Substitutions on the pizza, such as swapping olives for mushrooms, are accommodated without additional charge, and the resulting pie demonstrates a careful construction.

Service here is attentive, with staff offering direct recommendations that prove helpful. Portions, particularly for pasta dishes, have diminished, with a $20 plate providing less than previously observed. This reduction in size stands in contrast to the pricing, making the value proposition less compelling for returning patrons.

The pizza crust, once reliably crisp, has seen inconsistency, sometimes arriving with a limp structure. Instances of missing paid-for additions, such as garlic on the crust, have occurred. Barbecue wings have been noted for a mealy texture beneath an excessive coating of sauce, a notable departure from past quality.

Alibi Room
State Elite
3
Alibi Room
86.00
Score
85 Pike St #410, Seattle, WA 98101, USA

Alibi Room occupies a tucked-away corner near Pike Place Market. The space presents a dark, moody atmosphere punctuated by vibrant, lively music. This setting accommodates a range of gatherings, from dates to family outings, and is noted for its potent cocktails.

The brick oven yields pizzas with a notably thin crust. Selections include the Margherita, Pizza con Carne, and a Calzone. Sides such as roasted broccolini and apples with brie are also available.

Despite a generally positive impression, the pizzas themselves have drawn varied opinions, with some finding them wanting in their execution. The location, near the well-known gum wall, places it within a maze-like area.

Pizza Twist
State Elite
4
Pizza Twist
85.51
Score
12319 Roosevelt Way NE, Seattle, WA 98125, USA

Pizza Twist offers a departure from traditional pies with its paneer-centric offerings. The Achari, Tikka Masala, and Bombay Garlic pizzas were notable for their robust flavor profiles and generous, well-spiced toppings. The crust maintained a satisfying texture, providing a solid foundation for the distinctive combinations.

The establishment maintains a clean, well-lit environment. Service is efficient, with staff like Tage noted for friendly interaction and ensuring order accuracy during pickup. The restaurant accommodates large advance orders, ensuring readiness and temperature for timely collection.

Beyond pizza, the wings present a flavorful option. This particular location on Roosevelt Way NE stands out for its consistent execution and ingredient quality, setting a high standard compared to other branches.

Jackson Street Pizza Lounge
State Elite
5
Jackson Street Pizza Lounge
85.39
Score
2901 S Jackson St, Seattle, WA 98144, USA

Jackson Street Pizza Lounge offers a convivial neighborhood atmosphere. Conversations flowed easily with attentive staff, and one patron noted a bespoke cocktail, christened "The Dudelar Daiquiri," proved outstanding. The decor provides a pleasant backdrop for such interactions.

The Mushroom pie arrived with a promising appearance. However, its sauce lacked intensity, and one diner found the dough unpleasantly greasy. A pepperoni pizza, while featuring well-flavored toppings and a satisfying crunch, was perceived as undersized.

Despite varied impressions of the main offerings, the warmth of the staff consistently impressed. Servers like Jessi and Şirin are mentioned by name for their engaging and welcoming demeanor, making it a place patrons wish to revisit.

City Directory