Best Pizza in
Tennessee

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Tennessee to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
78.5
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Nashville
highest avg. score in Tennessee
Verified Deliveries
50
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
2
Memphis · Nashville

State Hall of Fame

Fox's Pizza Den
State Elite
1
Fox's Pizza Den
92.00
Score
2828 Elm Hill Pike #108, Nashville, TN 37214, USA

Fox's Pizza Den offers a straightforward approach to pizza. The dough, neither too thick nor too thin, serves as a capable foundation for toppings. The sauce provides a balanced tang, and the cheese achieves a satisfying melt.

The Stromboli presents a well-seasoned filling, a notable element of its construction. Accompanying this, a cheesesteak sub arrives generously portioned, its components, including mushrooms, peppers, and onions, clearly visible and abundant. Even a tossed salad exceeds expectations, incorporating bell peppers and cucumber.

For those inclined towards a beverage, the cappuccino provides a warm, sweet conclusion. The establishment is situated at 2828 Elm Hill Pike #108, Nashville, TN 37214.

Five Points Pizza East
State Elite
2
Five Points Pizza East
92.00
Score
1012 Woodland St, Nashville, TN 37206, USA

Five Points Pizza East offers New York-style pies with thin crusts and substantial slices. The crust achieves a crisp exterior with a yielding interior. Their tomato sauce balances tang and savory notes, complemented by generously applied, flavorful toppings.

Garlic knots arrive as substantial, aromatic twists. Basil-infused lemonade provides a refreshing counterpoint.

The atmosphere is laid-back, with efficient staff keeping pace even during busy periods.

Five Points Pizza West
State Elite
3
Five Points Pizza West
91.00
Score
4100 Charlotte Ave, Nashville, TN 37209, USA

Five Points Pizza West offers thin crust pies. Toppings are applied with an unsparing hand. Garlic knots arrive heavily perfumed.

The space accommodates diners at tables and a bar. Service maintains efficiency during busy periods. Staff handle inquiries and orders with competence.

Some slices are presented on thin paper plates. The location provides parking nearby.

Slim & Husky's Pizza (North Nashville)
State Elite
4
Slim & Husky's Pizza (North Nashville)
91.00
Score
911 Buchanan St, Nashville, TN 37208, USA

The North Nashville location of Slim & Husky's Pizza offers a robust pizza experience, with a distinctively seasoned crust that elevates its pies. The "Nothing But a V Thang" pizza, featuring classic red sauce and a medley of vegan toppings, exemplifies this thoughtful approach to ingredients. Sweet counterpoints are found in the Ms. Berry Cinnamon Roll, its blueberry sauce brightened by a lemon glaze.

Service encountered a hitch during a recent busy period. A significant wait preceded the arrival of the first dishes, and a portion of the order was initially missed, requiring further delay. Even early items, like cinnamon rolls, arrived cool, a point of contention given the establishment's quick-service model.

Despite service inconsistencies, the quality of the pizza itself garners praise. One patron reported receiving assistance with building entry due to a mobility issue, with staff offering detailed menu explanations. The food ultimately met or exceeded expectations, even for those braving inclement weather.

Bella Napoli Pizzeria
State Elite
5
Bella Napoli Pizzeria
90.81
Score
1200 Villa Pl #206, Nashville, TN 37212, USA

Bella Napoli's pizzas feature a thin crust, charred in spots from the oven, supporting a bright tomato sauce and generous toppings. The Isabella, a straightforward margherita variation, stands out with fresh mozzarella. Portions for entrees, such as the chicken parmesan, are substantial.

The atmosphere is lively, with staff moving efficiently through the dining room. Bartenders are attentive, and complimentary limoncello is offered to some patrons. Reservations are advisable, even for mid-week dining.

The tiramisu, while clearly made in-house, lacks the expected coffee and alcohol notes. A poorly steamed cappuccino also detracted from the beverage service.

City Directory