Best Pizza in
Indiana

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Indiana to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
78.6
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Indianapolis
highest avg. score in Indiana
Verified Deliveries
20
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
1
Indianapolis

State Hall of Fame

Bazbeaux
State Elite
1
Bazbeaux
90.00
Score
329 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

Bazbeaux on Mass Ave offers a substantial pizza, exemplified by the described *Colossus*. The crust provides a foundation for a generous topping distribution. Salads accompany the pies; however, the Caesar salad sometimes features less-than-ideal greens.

Service can navigate busy periods with efficiency, though attentiveness may vary. Staff remain engaged even during peak hours, preparing orders with promptness. The menu presents signature combinations alongside build-your-own options.

The *Tchoupitoulas* pizza, recommended by staff, displays a distinct flavor profile. This pie balances its components to achieve a notable taste.

Giordano's
State Elite
2
Giordano's
89.00
Score
4110 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250, USA

Giordano's on 82nd Street offers a robust deep-dish pizza experience. The stuffed varieties, particularly the Meat and More, provide a substantial meal, with one pizza easily serving four. The mozzarella triangles and marinara sauce are notable components, prepared with apparent care.

Service, when dining in, can be attentive without being intrusive. A server assisted with selections and checked in regularly. For carry-out, efficiency was observed during a busy Friday evening, with orders ready as expected.

The crust on the deep-dish pizza is a significant element, though occasionally it arrives overdone. The spinach white pizza on thin crust, however, is a well-received alternative.

ClusterTruck
State Elite
3
ClusterTruck
88.00
Score
729 N Pennsylvania St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

ClusterTruck's operation centers on a focused delivery model from its Pennsylvania Street location. Food arrives hot, as noted with a pizza featuring a fluffy crust, though it arrived slightly underdone. The mac and cheese lacked a desired creamy richness, presenting a rather bland profile.

One patron found the white chicken chili to be exceptional. However, the same order included a Pad Thai that deviated from expectation; noodles disintegrated, the sauce was excessively liquid and bore an unusual tomato-like sweetness, and the inclusion of cilantro was perplexing. The kitchen's approach to pickled onions also seemed improvised.

The establishment also offers a chicken Caesar wrap, described as a consistent go-to. A chicken masala and a Caesar chicken burrito were deemed good by another diner. To-go containers have been praised for their quality.

Bazbeaux Pizza
State Elite
4
Bazbeaux Pizza
86.00
Score
811 E Westfield Blvd, Indianapolis, IN 46220, USA

The Spicy Bee pizza offers a distinct balance of heat and sweetness, the hot honey clearly perceptible without overpowering. The Roma and Quattro Formaggio, each generously topped, showcase a rich, melted cheese blend. Garlic bread, both with and without cheese, presented a flavorful, complex starter.

Service instances include a server managing multiple tables with prepared checks. The Spinach Salad, dressed in a refreshing vinaigrette, stands out among side offerings. A group visit noted prompt seating and attentive server timing for appetizers and main courses.

Pizza crusts have been observed as inconsistently cooked, sometimes underdone. The establishment's history is tied to a quirky original location and a mascot named for culinary creativity.

Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub
State Elite
5
Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub
85.00
Score
65 E Pearl St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub offers a welcoming atmosphere with a notable drink selection. The spicy chicken and gorgonzola soup stands out, its layers of flavor evident in each spoonful.

The Chicken Alfredo Pizza provides a rich experience. For those with dietary concerns, the cauliflower crust pizza, topped with black olives, green peppers, and goat cheese, is a well-executed option. The staff readily assists with ingredient inquiries.

The Pearl Street salad surprised with its exceptional taste. The establishment maintains a warm and friendly environment.

City Directory